Weather or Not

Severe Outflow by R. Edwards

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives

Powered by Genesis

Truth vs. Bumper-Sticker Scientism

November 20, 2024 by tornado Leave a Comment

Quite often the subject of social-media memes, this is a well-known quote from a media-friendly astrophysicist of considerable fame.

“The good thing about science is that it’s true, whether or not you believe in it.”

— Neil deGrasse Tyson

This is a terrible quote and meme. Neil Tyson, of all people, should know better.

Instead, this is a typically haughty, shallow, bumper-sticker level of “new atheist” scientism, and way off-base anyway.

Science has been wrong and/or incomplete countless many times, and still is. Otherwise, there would be nothing more to do, no ideas worth change, and nothing to improve.

If science were categorically “true”, we’d never need retractions, nor corrigenda, nor errata, nor revisions, nor shifts in thinking from one explanatory theory to another. Done right, science continually updates what we thought could be true, or partway there, to something closer to the truth. But science is nonlinear, zig-zaggy, mistake-prone as humans are, and sometimes leads us into dead ends from which we have to backtrack before moving forward again.

I call bullshit on that quote, the arrogant attitude behind it and the implication that science monopolizes truth. I’ve had Tyson apologists respond stuff to the effect of, “He didn’t mean it…”. Then he shouldn’t have said it! Say what you mean, and mean what you say. For someone making a living as a science communicator, this was terrible communication, if unintended. I think it was intended. If not: communicate better. Talking down to your audience is hardly a way to garner attention needed for evoking better understanding by said audience.

Instead of “true”, I see science as an amazing, God-given pathway to understanding His infinite developments better and better by the year.

We should be humble enough to understand that complete truth is beyond our means and abilities, and that science is but one way of learning on the journey toward our ultimate destination.

Instead the meme should say: “The good thing about science is that it is iteratively self-correcting.”

I am fortunate enough to be a published natural scientist, in my case meteorology instead of astrophysics (though I did take an astrophysics course in college…it was fun and enlightening!). I strive not to be perfect, nor to know all that’s “true” (only God does), nor to be better than thou, but instead, to build upon the already substantial and imperfect understanding we have of some small part of our universe — in my case, dangerous weather. Sure, I may know more about severe weather than >99% of the population, through study, direct observation, research, and forecast experience. I’m considered an expert. And yet, my knowledge of it is, to use a vaguely theological theme, still but a single grain of sand on the seashore of understanding. Atmospheric-science ideas I may treat as “true” now may be amended a little or a lot, or even exterminated, upon future discovery and/or analysis. Good! That, friends, is science.

Nearly 35 years of full-time science to my name, and a lot of forecasts and research papers (per our respective CVs, twice as many lead-authored formal papers as NDGT, despite my being a full-time, shift-rotating forecaster the whole time), one thing I can say with great confidence that our science still has much to learn and much to improve. Otherwise your forecasts would be on the mark all the time, even though they are a lot better than 35 years ago! I hope my peers and I have helped to steer it on a truer course, even if its “truth” is far from perfect or complete, or has been the case often throughout history, not true upon further study, and requiring revision.

Filed Under: Weather AND Not Tagged With: arrogance, astrophysics, communication, communication skills, meteorology, Neil DeGrasse Tyson, science, science communication, science education, scientific method, scientists

Scientific Authorship and the Autism/Vaccinations Scandal

January 7, 2011 by tornado Leave a Comment

If you haven’t been tent-camping in the steppes of Kazakhstan for a few weeks, you’ve heard by now that the so-called “research” linking common childhood vaccines to autism is totally worthless garbage.

The first page of the Lancet paper can be found here. Sounds familiar? It should. Breathless mass-media publicity of this phony study left millions of parents around the globe aflutter with ultimately unfounded paranoia that their kids would be mired in the darkest catacombs of autism at the hands of heretofore innocuous inoculations. Worst, it caused countless children needless suffering and damage.

How was the deception revealed and scuppered? It wasn’t scientific peers, who clearly slacked off the formal review process for which they were responsible (otherwise this big lie wouldn’t have been published!). Nor was it the manuscript editor, who obviously let this slide through insufficiently thorough oversight. Instead, it took a man outside the science–several years later into a new decade–to expose the big fat fraud. It also goes to show that investigative journalism still can serve a noble purpose, at least when the reporter has more than a meniscus-thin familiarity with the subject at hand (a sadly uncommon condition in scientific reporting, as pointedly discussed by a highly accomplished atmospheric scientist).

Science matters. Excellent science matters more. It therefore troubles me to see science as a whole (even if a completely different specialty than mine) besmirched by the widely publicized and heinous actions of one ethically corrupt medical “researcher”…and as I’ll discuss more, the gross negligence of his co-authors!

Numerous children worldwide have become ill unnecessarily, and some died, as a result of the vendetta-driven agenda of one “scientist” as manifest in a bogus, contrived research paper. That’s the most important impact; and if there’s any criminal and civil law that covers Wakefield et al’s deceptions and outright fabrications, it should be rained down upon them with full shock-and-awe force.

Notice I said “them” and not “him.” Yes, Wakefield (lead author) isn’t the only guilty party. The twelve–that’s right, 12!–listed coauthors (Murch, Anthony, Linnell, Casson, Malik, Berelowitz, Dhillon, Thomson, Harvey, Valentine, Davies, and Walker-Smith), signed off on the work too by agreeing to be listed as such; and they have a direct ethical culpability in this debacle!

In that vein, a strikingly candid and forceful BMJ editorial hammered a fierce blow upon the topic of frivolous co-authorship–namely, the responsibilities of co-authors in the manuscript-composition process:

    There are hard lessons for many in this highly damaging saga. Firstly, for the coauthors. The GMC panel was clear that it was Wakefield alone who wrote the final version of the paper. His coauthors seem to have been unaware of what he was doing under the cover of their names and reputations. As the GMC panel heard, they did not even know which child was which in the paper’s patient anonymised text and tables. However, this does not absolve them. Although only two (John Walker-Smith and Simon Murch) were charged by the GMC, and only one, the paper’s senior author Walker-Smith, was found guilty of misconduct, they all failed in their duties as authors. The satisfaction of adding to one’s CV must never detract from the responsibility to ensure that one has been neither party to nor duped by a fraud. This means that coauthors will have to check the source data of studies more thoroughly than many do at present—or alternatively describe in a contributor’s statement precisely which bits of the source data they take responsibility for.

Damn right, “they all failed in their duties as authors.” This is a sore spot, a pet peeve, a topic about which I’ve written before. Frivolous and excessive authorship is a festering carbuncle inside the underwear of science, and this incident shows one major reason for that.

The cold truth: Every single person listed as a co-author is responsible for everything in a paper, by virtue of his or her name appearing there! If anything is fraudulent or more than trivially erroneous anywhere in a paper, the scientific integrity of every author (not just whichever unrecorded one who actually handled the bad portion) is at stake.

Unsolicited advice for potential paper authors:

1. Don’t be one unless you actually wrote some of the paper or contributed substantive analysis and/or insight.

2. Inform all prospective authors, right at the start, that you expect their substantive contribution to the process all the way through the end of formal reviews.

3. Do you feel political pressure to add an author? Ignore it. Screw politics! Don’t add an author unless he/she actually has contributed substantially to the research or review in some crucial way (writing and editing, data provision and analysis, key insight without which some nontrivial part of the paper is impossible, etc.).

4. If you’re the lead author, clearly implore every single co-author, individually, to proofread the entire paper (not just their contribution) at least once before submission, and during each state of revision.

5. If any “author” hasn’t fulfilled his/her role duly, drop them from the list and move them to the Acknowledgments until and unless that changes for the better. It’s a simple as highlighting and deleting the number of characters in their name and affiliation and pasting them elsewhere–a three-second exercise with mouse and keyboard.

6. Provide all reviews of the paper to all authors, along with your proposed replies, before sending back the revision.

7. If you are a non-lead author, insist on performing a timely, pre-submission review of the paper, do it with a fine-toothed comb, and save a copy of your “internal” review. Your very reputation is on the line! [You should save copies of all reviews you ever do for any manuscript, formal or informal, anyway.]

I’m sure one or more among the many scientists with more experience and education than I, will have even more handy advice; but that should suffice for starters.

[EDIT: One of those more experienced and educated scientists has posted a fine response to this topic, dealing with the issue of trust.]

Filed Under: Not weather Tagged With: autism, autism and vaccinations, ethics, measles, mumps, science, science journals, scientific authorship, scientific ethics, scientific fraud, scientific method, scientific misconduct, vaccinations

Public Consequences of Sloppy Science

November 18, 2008 by tornado Leave a Comment

Unless you’ve been comatose, camping in the Everglades, hiking the South Georgia Islands or lying wasted in a tiki hut outside Cabo Wabo, this shouldn’t be news by now: James Hansen’s NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS) has been revealed to have used a subset of bad (temporally displaced September) thermal data in averaging worldwide surface temperatures for October.

Oops? Sure, we’ve all made mistakes in science, at some level. But errors have degrees of importance, and given its context, this was a major whopper. While this blunder doesn’t necessarily discredit or debunk previous work, as the most zealous of skeptics would desire, it does raise doubts. Any such basic, preventable quality control error does call into question their oversight, and as such, their devotion to accuracy in analysis — past as well as present and future. Because what they do is so high in profile, this error has and will garner adverse media attention.

This is where it goes from “oops” to “oh sh|t.” Whether or not in the public eye, time-checking one’s observational input data is so fundamental to analytic integrity that neglecting to do so is a scientific blunder of the highest order. This applies whatever the data source. It is the responsibility of the scientist(s) in charge of the analysis to verify its veracity.

Most of the time, the scientists, reviewers or oversight body notices such an error, the data is corrected and re-analyzed, and life goes on, the humiliation limited to a small and often forgiving scientific circle of as little as one member. However, for “leading scientists” in a highly visible, heavily scrutinized and controversial specialty to fail to QC new data before analyzing, posting and promoting it in public…absolutely inexcusable! If outright falsification is the scientific equivalent of murder (e.g., the disbarred Korean geneticist), failure to QC your data (especially for something so simple as time range) is tantamount to scientific negligent homicide.

There is a lesson here. If you “don’t have the resources” to QC your results, don’t post them until you do! When it comes time to publish actual papers in the future, I do hope for their sake that the formal review process does its job with utmost rigor, and any such blunders are caught. This is one reason that “Let it publish before letting it public” is a good idea. As a fellow scientist of the atmosphere, I recommend Dr. Hansen and crew do just that, or risk further embarrassment, skepticism (warranted or not) and damage to credibility.

Filed Under: Weather Tagged With: climate change, climate science, GISS, global warming, James Hansen, NASA Goddard, scientific method

Search

Recent Posts

  • Brief History of Shift Rotation in NWS
  • A.I. as a Scientific Reviewer?
  • Token Participation for a Check Box
  • Public Access to Public Land
  • Independent Review Needed for Weather Disasters and Warning Verification

Categories

  • Not weather
  • Photographic Adventures
  • Scattershooting
  • Weather
  • Weather AND Not

Blogroll

  • CanadianTexan
  • Chuck's Chatter
  • Cliff Mass Weather & Climate
  • Digital Photography Review
  • DMN Dallas Cowboys BLOG
  • Dr. Cook's Blog
  • Dr. JimmyC
  • E-journal of Severe Storms Meteorology
  • Eloquent Science
  • Image of the Week
  • Jack's Cam Wall
  • Jim LaDue View
  • Laura Ingraham
  • MADWEATHER
  • Michelle Malkin
  • Photography Attorney
  • Severe Weather Notes
  • SkyPix by Roger Edwards
  • Tornatrix
  • With All My Mind

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Recent Posts

  • Brief History of Shift Rotation in NWS
  • A.I. as a Scientific Reviewer?
  • Token Participation for a Check Box
  • Public Access to Public Land
  • Independent Review Needed for Weather Disasters and Warning Verification

Categories

  • Not weather
  • Photographic Adventures
  • Scattershooting
  • Weather
  • Weather AND Not

Archives

Blogroll

  • CanadianTexan
  • Chuck's Chatter
  • Cliff Mass Weather & Climate
  • Digital Photography Review
  • DMN Dallas Cowboys BLOG
  • Dr. Cook's Blog
  • Dr. JimmyC
  • E-journal of Severe Storms Meteorology
  • Eloquent Science
  • Image of the Week
  • Jack's Cam Wall
  • Jim LaDue View
  • Laura Ingraham
  • MADWEATHER
  • Michelle Malkin
  • Photography Attorney
  • Severe Weather Notes
  • SkyPix by Roger Edwards
  • Tornatrix
  • With All My Mind

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org