Weather or Not

Severe Outflow by R. Edwards

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives

Powered by Genesis

Truth vs. Bumper-Sticker Scientism

November 20, 2024 by tornado Leave a Comment

Quite often the subject of social-media memes, this is a well-known quote from a media-friendly astrophysicist of considerable fame.

“The good thing about science is that it’s true, whether or not you believe in it.”

— Neil deGrasse Tyson

This is a terrible quote and meme. Neil Tyson, of all people, should know better.

Instead, this is a typically haughty, shallow, bumper-sticker level of “new atheist” scientism, and way off-base anyway.

Science has been wrong and/or incomplete countless many times, and still is. Otherwise, there would be nothing more to do, no ideas worth change, and nothing to improve.

If science were categorically “true”, we’d never need retractions, nor corrigenda, nor errata, nor revisions, nor shifts in thinking from one explanatory theory to another. Done right, science continually updates what we thought could be true, or partway there, to something closer to the truth. But science is nonlinear, zig-zaggy, mistake-prone as humans are, and sometimes leads us into dead ends from which we have to backtrack before moving forward again.

I call bullshit on that quote, the arrogant attitude behind it and the implication that science monopolizes truth. I’ve had Tyson apologists respond stuff to the effect of, “He didn’t mean it…”. Then he shouldn’t have said it! Say what you mean, and mean what you say. For someone making a living as a science communicator, this was terrible communication, if unintended. I think it was intended. If not: communicate better. Talking down to your audience is hardly a way to garner attention needed for evoking better understanding by said audience.

Instead of “true”, I see science as an amazing, God-given pathway to understanding His infinite developments better and better by the year.

We should be humble enough to understand that complete truth is beyond our means and abilities, and that science is but one way of learning on the journey toward our ultimate destination.

Instead the meme should say: “The good thing about science is that it is iteratively self-correcting.”

I am fortunate enough to be a published natural scientist, in my case meteorology instead of astrophysics (though I did take an astrophysics course in college…it was fun and enlightening!). I strive not to be perfect, nor to know all that’s “true” (only God does), nor to be better than thou, but instead, to build upon the already substantial and imperfect understanding we have of some small part of our universe — in my case, dangerous weather. Sure, I may know more about severe weather than >99% of the population, through study, direct observation, research, and forecast experience. I’m considered an expert. And yet, my knowledge of it is, to use a vaguely theological theme, still but a single grain of sand on the seashore of understanding. Atmospheric-science ideas I may treat as “true” now may be amended a little or a lot, or even exterminated, upon future discovery and/or analysis. Good! That, friends, is science.

Nearly 35 years of full-time science to my name, and a lot of forecasts and research papers (per our respective CVs, twice as many lead-authored formal papers as NDGT, despite my being a full-time, shift-rotating forecaster the whole time), one thing I can say with great confidence that our science still has much to learn and much to improve. Otherwise your forecasts would be on the mark all the time, even though they are a lot better than 35 years ago! I hope my peers and I have helped to steer it on a truer course, even if its “truth” is far from perfect or complete, or has been the case often throughout history, not true upon further study, and requiring revision.

Filed Under: Weather AND Not Tagged With: arrogance, astrophysics, communication, communication skills, meteorology, Neil DeGrasse Tyson, science, science communication, science education, scientific method, scientists

Scattershooting 181203

December 3, 2018 by tornado Leave a Comment

Scattershooting while wondering what happened to respect for the Constitution precisely as it was literally written…

NEIL TYSON SEXUAL MISCONDUCT ALLEGATIONS: Famous astrophysicist Neil DeGrasse Tyson has been accused of sexual misconduct. Did it happen? I don’t know and you don’t either. Still, as he noted in his eloquent and dignified response, even if the majority of the accused are guilty, some are not, and due process is needed. I’ll add, ALL accused in this nation are Constitutionally entitled to due process. The lynch mob of social-media opinion is unhelpful. Yes, I am aware of the overtones of the latter sentence, and yes, I state it deliberately, because it applies to these situations, as it did to Clarence Thomas and Brett Kavanaugh.

False accusations also do happen. The Duke Lacrosse and UVA Rolling Stone events are high-profile examples, and thousands more men (including at least two I know) have been accused falsely. Was Tyson? Or is he just lying in an eloquent and dignified manner? Again, you don’t know and neither do I. Other hot takes here that I’ve seen on Twitter include patently irrational ones to the effect of, “He’s guilty, because all men are to some extent”, “Believe her no matter what” and the dangerous and hypocritical, “Even if he’s innocent, the sacrifice of innocent men is worth it if it means justice in the end.” So instead of rushing to conclusions (were you in those rooms?), why don’t we be *mature* about this, avoid hot takes and “instapundit” reactions, evaluate credibility with facts, logic and reason (not emotion), and wait until more actual evidence arises, one way or another.

…

PLAYOFF-BOUND SOONERS AGAIN: Beating the Whorns is a great occasion whenever it can happen, but especially in the Big 12 (-3) Championship game in JerryWorld. As Lincoln Riley rightly noted, OU earned the final playoff spot by beating every team on the schedule (including the one to which they had a close loss earlier). If other teams’ fans want to complain, my answer is straightforward: don’t get blown out by Purdue (tOSU) nor lose twice, including by 20+ to LSU (UGa). That said, as in the last two playoff appearances, and despite an insanely good offense led by the sort of dual-threat dynamo at QB that historically has given Saban defenses fits, expectations are tempered by a lack of defensive skill and talent that an occasional big turnover play only can cover so much. Yes, most of this defense’s problems are related to lack of talent. That is not going to go away in one month. Until OU recruits taller, stronger, stickier defensive backs, and gets back to bringing in powerful, disruptive interior defensive linemen in the Tommie Harris and Gerald McCoy modes, who can generate upfield pressure and collapse the pocket, improved coaching or scheming (which aren’t that evident yet) are only going to go so far. So we have no pass rush at all, and the secondary is undersized and easily confused. A high-scoring playoff loss is in OUr future, but regardless, it has been a fun and exciting season, one to remember well regardless of playoff results.

…

PUBLICITY STUNTS in the SOCIAL-MEDIA ERA: Hey kiddos, the screen-capture below represents an outstanding example of what we know as a publicity stunt, as well as people falling for it. This is an activity designed to portray an image via social media, a form of passive-aggressive psychological manipulation. They’re crooks, but not dummies. They knew this would be filmed and propagated. Scanning Twitter responses and retweets, I see plenty of suckers for this false “commoner” schtick, despite the fabulous wealth and dubious history of both of these individuals. “No security”? That’s crap too. Bet your life savings there’s undercover Secret Service seated very near, since one of the passengers is an ex-President.

…

R.I.P. GEORGE H.W. BUSH:
Our 41st President, George H.W. Bush, has passed on, and now is reunited with his bride of 73 years, Barbara. He is the only person I’ve met who ever was President. Then-Vice-President Bush visited an “at risk” youth job fair I was attending in Dallas in 1985, and I shook his hand and had a brief conversation. I was there seeking part-time summer work opportunities, and he was pleasant, congenial and seemed genuinely curious about my aspirations. I later didn’t agree with some of his presidential decisions; nevertheless, my admiration of him was and remains large. I don’t regret voting for him twice, especially given the alternatives, and thoroughly enjoyed my visit to his interesting and insightful library and museum in College Station. Few ever served this greatest of nations so long and honorably, from before the Japanese shot his plane down in the Pacific theater of WW2 to his successful fight to get Nixon out of office, loyal service to the great Ronald Reagan, to his post-presidential charitable works. Bush was a good man who fought for his nation in battle and inside the Beltway…and a statesman the likes of whom we haven’t seen in the presidency since. Much respect…

Filed Under: Scattershooting Tagged With: cancel culture, college football, due process, football, George H.W. Bush, harassment, hypocrisy, left-wing hypocrisy, Neil DeGrasse Tyson, Oklahoma Sooners, social media

Search

Recent Posts

  • Brief History of Shift Rotation in NWS
  • A.I. as a Scientific Reviewer?
  • Token Participation for a Check Box
  • Public Access to Public Land
  • Independent Review Needed for Weather Disasters and Warning Verification

Categories

  • Not weather
  • Photographic Adventures
  • Scattershooting
  • Weather
  • Weather AND Not

Blogroll

  • CanadianTexan
  • Chuck's Chatter
  • Cliff Mass Weather & Climate
  • Digital Photography Review
  • DMN Dallas Cowboys BLOG
  • Dr. Cook's Blog
  • Dr. JimmyC
  • E-journal of Severe Storms Meteorology
  • Eloquent Science
  • Image of the Week
  • Jack's Cam Wall
  • Jim LaDue View
  • Laura Ingraham
  • MADWEATHER
  • Michelle Malkin
  • Photography Attorney
  • Severe Weather Notes
  • SkyPix by Roger Edwards
  • Tornatrix
  • With All My Mind

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Recent Posts

  • Brief History of Shift Rotation in NWS
  • A.I. as a Scientific Reviewer?
  • Token Participation for a Check Box
  • Public Access to Public Land
  • Independent Review Needed for Weather Disasters and Warning Verification

Categories

  • Not weather
  • Photographic Adventures
  • Scattershooting
  • Weather
  • Weather AND Not

Archives

Blogroll

  • CanadianTexan
  • Chuck's Chatter
  • Cliff Mass Weather & Climate
  • Digital Photography Review
  • DMN Dallas Cowboys BLOG
  • Dr. Cook's Blog
  • Dr. JimmyC
  • E-journal of Severe Storms Meteorology
  • Eloquent Science
  • Image of the Week
  • Jack's Cam Wall
  • Jim LaDue View
  • Laura Ingraham
  • MADWEATHER
  • Michelle Malkin
  • Photography Attorney
  • Severe Weather Notes
  • SkyPix by Roger Edwards
  • Tornatrix
  • With All My Mind

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org